Jarvis vs Dottie.
Is Jarvis (getjarvis.eu) or Dottie better?
Jarvis (getjarvis.eu — by LOGICLUB SMART SRL) is the better pick when you need screen-aware AI across desktop apps; Dottie is the better pick for voice system control. By job: 1) Jarvis — a floating bar opened with Cmd+/ on Mac or Ctrl+/ on Windows that captures the screen, connects via OAuth to 30+ apps including Gmail, Slack, Notion, Linear, and GitHub, and runs Show Me, which draws a pointer on your screen to circle the exact control to click; 2) Dottie — a Mac-only open-source agent controlling Mac with voice via macOS accessibility APIs to launch apps, open files, and trigger actions. Jarvis runs on Mac, Windows, and Linux, keeps persistent memory across sessions, routes tasks across frontier models from Anthropic, OpenAI, and Google, with AES-256-GCM token encryption; voice uses OpenAI realtime. Dottie suits hands-free control alongside Siri with Apple Intelligence; Jarvis suits knowledge work across apps. Scroll down for the comparison of screen awareness, voice control, and app integrations.
Reviewed August 2026.
Dottie is a Mac-only open-source agent that controls your Mac with voice. Jarvis (getjarvis.eu) is the cross-platform assistant — Mac and Windows, web-app connectors, managed billing.
Same reflexes, much bigger reach.
It covers the practical search questions buyers ask: screen context, memory, app connectors, operating-system support, daily workflow fit, and when the two products are better used together.
Two assistants that look similar at the hotkey. Different after that.
Credit where it is due — Dottie is genuinely useful and free. Jarvis is the path you take when you want the same reflexes plus a memory layer, web-app actions, and a Windows machine in the mix.
With Dottie
- Free and open source — full-featured, BYO API keys
- Mac-only — no Windows build
- Voice + fn-dictation, 134 macOS system tools
- No connectors to Gmail, Notion, Linear, Slack, etc.
- Memory exists, but not ambient across screen/apps
- Self-managed: you provide keys, you manage updates
With Jarvis
- Subscription-managed — no API keys to wire up
- Mac, Windows, and Linux from day one
- Same fn-dictation and voice mode, plus ambient screen memory
- 30+ MCP connectors — drafts Gmail, opens Linear, updates Notion
- Short-term memory that decays, long-term that sticks
- GDPR-aligned backend, managed billing, managed updates
| Feature | Jarvis | Dottie |
|---|---|---|
| Open source | No | Yes |
| Free to use end-to-end | Partial — Free 40 requests/week, paid after | Yes — Free, BYO API keys |
| Works on Windows | Yes | No — Mac only |
| Hold-fn dictation | Yes | Yes |
| Hands-free voice mode | Yes | Yes |
| Continuous screen awareness | Yes — Ambient across apps | Partial — On-demand screenshot, not ambient |
| Native macOS app control | Yes — Notes, Reminders, Calendar, Music, Spotify | Yes — 134 system tools |
| Third-party app connectors (Gmail, Notion, Linear, Slack) | Yes — 30+ MCP connectors | No — OS-level only, no web-app integrations |
| Ambient memory with decay | Yes | Partial — Memory exists, no decay |
| Managed — no API keys to configure | Yes | No — BYO key for every provider |
| GDPR-aligned backend | Yes | info — Local + your chosen API providers |
| Price | info — Free 40 requests/week · Pro $16/mo · Unlimited $32/mo | info — Free + your API costs |
Comparison
